In Red Dead Redemption 2, completing errand requests for fellow camp members is one of the best ways to earn honor and unique rewards. One of the earliest requests comes from young Jack Marston, who asks Arthur Morgan to help him locate a replacement comic book after losing his original copy. Tracking down a Penny Dreadful book allows players to experience rewarding exploration while discovering hidden spots across the open world.
How to Trigger Jack's Book Request
To unlock Jack's item request, you must progress into Chapter 2 of the main campaign. Specifically, you need to complete the story mission titled A Fisher of Men, where Arthur takes young Jack fishing near the river. Shortly after returning to camp, speaking with Jack will trigger a conversation about his lost adventure stories.
Top Locations to Find a Penny Dreadful Book
There are multiple locations across the map where players can retrieve a suitable book for Jack. One accessible spot is at Clawson's Rest, a small cabin situated northwest of Valentine across the Dakota River. Another popular destination is Osman's Grove, located east of Emerald Station, where a book rests inside a quiet wooden shack.
Additional Spots and Exploration Tips
For players exploring further south, a copy can also be found in the abandoned settlement of Pleasance in Lemoyne. Visiting Downes Ranch also yields a copy sitting on a bedroom nightstand in the main homestead. Keep in mind that finding just one of these books satisfies the quest requirement for Jack.
Returning the Book and Claiming Rewards
Once you grab a Penny Dreadful book from any of the available locations, return to the Van der Linde gang's active camp. Interact with Jack to hand over the item, which immediately improves Arthur's overall honor rating. In addition to boosting camp morale, Jack will present you with a chocolate bar as a sweet token of appreciation.
